Revolut is under pressure from its auditors to improve internal controls after UK regulators highlighted significant flaws in the auditing of its accounts, including an “unacceptably high” risk of “material misstatement”.
The rapidly growing payments group, which has suffered a string of high-profile defections in its risk and compliance teams in recent months, is the unnamed “financial services provider” whose audit by BDO was criticised by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) in its latest audit quality inspections, people familiar with the matter told the Financial Times.
BDO’s audit of the unnamed company suffered from an “inadequate” approach to revenue recognition and “as a result, the risk of an undetected material misstatement was unacceptably high”, the FRC said in its annual report on the quality of the accounting firm’s work, published in July.
The watchdog also highlighted deficiencies in how Revolut’s payment processes were tested by BDO, the UK’s fifth-largest audit firm by revenue, which it said could have led to “material misstatements”.
Markets in Vienna or Christmas at The Shelbourne? 10 holiday escapes over the festive season
Ciara Mageean: ‘I just felt numb. It wasn’t even sadness, it was just emptiness’
Stealth sackings: why do employers fire staff for minor misdemeanours?
Carl and Gerty Cori: a Nobel Prizewinning husband and wife team
“The auditors are being significantly more challenging now, because they’re getting beaten up by their regulators,” one of the people familiar with the situation told the Financial Times, adding that BDO’s more rigorous approach could lead to delays in filing accounts for key Revolut subsidiaries.
Revolut Group Holdings Ltd, the group’s parent company, and Revolut Ltd must file 2021 accounts by the end of September. Accounts have been overdue since June 10 for Revolut NewCo UK, the entity intended to house the UK banking licence applied for by Revolut in January 2021, but which it still has not received. Other UK subsidiaries including Revolut FIC Ltd, which handles digital assets, and Revolut Travel Ltd, are also due to file at the end of September.
While delays in filing accounts are rarely punished, they can lead to the prosecution of company directors, which include Revolut chief executive Nikolay Storonsky, and civil penalties against the company itself under UK law.
Revolut must improve “unsexy things like its back office and controls” because it “needs to have a back office like a bank and it’s got the culture of a tech firm”, said a second person familiar with the situation.
The FRC had concluded that the fintech group “needs to have the control environment of a bank”, said this person, adding that Revolut was “definitely trying to do all the right things” and that management understood they needed to invest in processes and controls.
A company’s internal controls include the systems and processes that ensure its financial reporting is reliable and that it complies with its legal and regulatory obligations.
Revolut is Europe’s second most valuable private fintech, securing a price tag of $33bn in an $800mn funding round led by SoftBank and Tiger Global last year. It recorded a net loss of £168mn in its most recent annual results, for 2020.
It suffered an exodus of senior staff in recent months, including its UK money laundering reporting officer, UK chief risk officer, UK data protection officer and both UK and global heads of regulatory compliance. Revolut is still awaiting its banking licence in the UK.
Revolut is also the last company that applied that is still awaiting permanent approval by the FCA to offer cryptocurrency services in the UK. The FCA, which is looking solely at whether crypto groups have adequate anti-money laundering processes, in March announced that a “small number” of companies could remain on a temporary register for crypto firms until their applications had been fully processed.
BDO, which was paid £650,000 for checking Revolut’s 2020 financial statements, was criticised by the FRC in July for the “unacceptable” quality of its audits. Just seven of its 12 company audits reviewed in the FRC’s most recent annual inspections were deemed up to scratch.
Auditors are under increasing pressure from the regulator to resist companies’ demands to sign off accounts on time if management has not provided the necessary information. The shares of UK-listed groups such as S4 Capital and Revolution Beauty have been suspended this year because of delays in publishing their annual results.
Revolut declined to comment. BDO said it could not comment on individual companies it worked for. The FRC declined to comment. — Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2022
