“Cheers,” a woman says in a video on TikTok as she raises a shot glass filled with alcohol to the camera. She tips it back, grimaces and then sticks out her tongue in disgust.
“It’s medicinal; it’s medicinal,” she reminds herself.
The reason for the shot was a recent meal, which she worried may have given her food poisoning, she said. And she had read in a study that because “alcohol is a steriliser,” it can protect against food-borne illness.
But can it really?
The Penguin review: Colin Farrell’s powerhouse performance is the best thing about this Batman spin-off
An Irish man in California: what I did first notice was how people talk about themselves. Compared to the typical older Irish man
City centre sanctuary: No upgrades needed at architect’s renovated redbrick cottage for €435,000
As a teenage girl in the 1990s there was a level of harassment that I hope is unthinkable now
There may be an ounce of truth to the notion that drinking alcohol around the time you eat contaminated food can reduce the chances of food poisoning, experts said. But the evidence to support the claim is limited. And depending on how much you drink, alcohol could hurt your immune system more than it might help. Here’s what we know.
What the research suggests
Several small studies on food-borne illness outbreaks have indeed found that consuming alcohol was associated with protection from food poisoning, but they all have limitations.
In the study cited in the TikTok video, which was published in 2002, researchers described a salmonella outbreak that began at a 120-person banquet in Spain. At least 47 people became ill with vomiting or diarrhoea, along with stomach cramps, fever or headache, after consuming contaminated tuna sandwiches and potato salad. The researchers found that those who reported having three or more drinks at the celebration were 46 per cent less likely to become ill than those who didn’t drink, and those who had up to three drinks were 27 per cent less likely to develop symptoms.
Likewise, in a 1992 study of a 61-person outbreak of hepatitis A from raw oysters in Florida in the US, researchers found that those who reported drinking wine, whiskey or cocktails with the oysters were 90 per cent less likely to get sick than those who did not drink. Those who consumed beer, however, did not seem to be protected – the researchers hypothesised this was perhaps because beer has a lower alcohol concentration than the other beverages.
These studies support the theory that alcohol might interrupt the pathogens in people’s guts before they can cause illness, said Donald Schaffner, a professor of food science at Rutgers University in New Jersey. This is plausible, he said, since alcohol can kill bacteria and inactivate some viruses; that’s why it’s used in hand sanitisers and surface disinfectants.
But these small, decades-old studies can only show correlations between drinking and fewer illnesses; they can’t prove that alcohol prevented food poisoning, said Matthew Moore, an associate professor of food science at the University of Massachusetts Amherst.
He recommended taking those findings “with a serious grain of salt”.
It’s possible, for example, that some of the people who didn’t drink in those studies were abstaining for health reasons, which could have explained why they were more susceptible to food poisoning.
Researchers have not directly tested how drinking might influence food poisoning risk in a clinical trial, which could control for differences between people who do and don’t drink, Moore said. And in at least one outbreak of 33 people sickened with hepatitis E from shellfish on a cruise, researchers came to a different conclusion: Only those who drank alcohol were infected while the abstainers remained healthy.
Alcohol might weaken your immune system
Your chance of getting sick from contaminated food can depend on various factors, including your health, the amount of pathogen present, the type of food and how much of it you ate, said Craig Hedberg, an epidemiologist and food safety expert at the University of Minnesota. How alcohol plays into that is not well researched in humans, he said. But in a 2001 study, scientists found that although red and white wine killed salmonella in Petri dishes, feeding it to mice did nothing to protect them when they consumed the bacteria.
If you drink too much, it’s also possible that alcohol might make your intestine more susceptible to infections, said Dr Gyongyi Szabo, a gastroenterologist and professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School.
Research from Szabo and her colleagues has suggested that binge drinking – defined as four to five or more drinks in about two hours for most adults – can cause inflammation and signs of “leakiness” in the gut lining, which can allow bacteria and toxins to more easily enter the blood.
[ We are falling out of love with booze: Why Ireland is drinking lessOpens in new window ]
It’s also clear that heavy, chronic drinking can reduce your immune system’s ability to fight infections, she said. Research has shown, for example, that people with alcohol use disorder are more susceptible to illness or even death from certain food-borne infections such as listeria and vibrio.
And alcohol can cause dehydration, which may worsen food poisoning symptoms and prolong recovery time, experts said.
How to protect yourself from food poisoning
Drinking alcohol is an unproven and potentially risky approach to preventing food poisoning, experts said.
“It would be better just to not eat the dodgy food to begin with,” Schaffner said – though he acknowledged that it’s often not possible to tell if a particular food is contaminated.
A good way to stay safe is to pay attention to food recalls, Schaffner said. And in the kitchen, use proper food safety techniques. Those include washing your hands often; avoiding cross contamination from raw meat, poultry and fish by keeping those items separate from other foods; cooking all foods to proper temperatures; and avoiding leaving perishable foods at room temperature for more than two hours.
These strategies are especially important for people who are most susceptible to severe illness from food-borne pathogens, including those with weakened immune systems, or those who are pregnant, younger than 5 or older than 65.
Moore acknowledged that the proven ways to prevent food poisoning are “kind of boring.”
But they’re effective, he said, and that’s what matters.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
2024 The New York Times Company