Holmes beats off the moderns as Britain's top sleuth

BRITAIN: Number 221b Baker Street in London was a place for celebration yesterday as Sherlock Holmes was voted Britain's favourite…

BRITAIN: Number 221b Baker Street in London was a place for celebration yesterday as Sherlock Holmes was voted Britain's favourite fictional sleuth. "Elementary, my dear Watson," as the great man himself might have said.  Róisín Ingle reports

The pipe-smoking creation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle beat stiff competition from Agatha Christie's Hercule Poirot and Colin Dexter's Inspector Morse.

Almost a third (27 per cent) of participants in a poll run by booksdirect.co.uk voted for Holmes. Moustache-twirling Poirot received 16 per cent of the vote while Morse, played by the late John Thaw on television, came in a close third with 15 per cent.

"There were votes for a great range of fictional sleuths, but the mass appeal remains for the old favourites such as Holmes and Poirot," said Ms Lisa Milton, editorial director of mail-order bookseller BCA.

READ MORE

"But it was great to see some more recent characters appearing so far up the poll," she added.

Only two women made it into the top 10: Christie's homely if cunning Miss Marple and medical examiner Kay Scarpetta, the creation of American author Patricia Cornwell.

However, a number of women appeared elsewhere in the poll, including Sue Grafton's private detective Kinsey Millhone.

Most of the detectives in the top 10 were British and from non-violent books.