A committee of inquiry set up by the Archbishop of Tuam, Dr Michael Neary, has concluded there is no evidence of "supernatural phenomena of whatever kind" at the House of Prayer at Achill, Co Mayo. The special committee, of two priests and a nun, investigated miraculous claims by Mrs Christina Gallagher who lives at the house. None of the evidence presented to the committee proved beyond reasonable doubt the occurrence of supernatural phenomena there "other than that of faith".
In a statement last night, Dr Neary said Mrs Gallagher and her associates retained the right to believe and state their belief that such phenomena had taken place and continued to take place.
"The question, as far as competent ecclesiastical authority is concerned, remains open and unproven," he said.
He spoke of "the force for good" of those associated with the House of Prayer, and said there was no reason to question the sincerity or orthodoxy of those involved. His chief concern, however, was that the House be integrated into the life of Achill parish and the archdiocese. He was also concerned that it adhere more closely to an understanding arrived at with the former archbishop of Tuam, Dr Cassidy.
Towards both ends, and by agreement with Mrs Gallagher and her associates, the House of Prayer is to become a private association of the Christian faithful. Members of such associations operate in conformity with the church's code of canon law. It will submit statutes to Dr Neary for approval, which will include a clear and unambiguous statement of the purposes of the association and the means of achieving them.
The new association will be subject to Dr Neary's authority in all matters concerning funds, and in the use to which the funds may be put. Its chapel will be designated a private chapel. The parish priest of Achill will ex officio be chaplain, and his curate will be assistant chaplain. No other priest may celebrate Mass there without Dr Neary's permission.
If a spiritual director is required, members may choose one from among those legitimately exercising ministry in the Tuam archdiocese, subject to Dr Neary's approval.
The work of the association will be carried out at the premises currently occupied by the House of Prayer and at no other location. Dr Neary said he looked forward to working closely with members of the new association.
