A garda harassed a female sergeant by sending her a Valentine's Card, numerous emails and a friend request on Facebook despite numerous warnings from his superiors not to have any contact with her.
Gerardine Small BL, prosecuting told a Dublin Circuit Criminal Court jury that the fact Garda Donal Maguire harassed the married woman was not disputed, but rather the jurors had to determine if he was suffering from a mental disorder at the time.
Garda Maguire (40) of Rock Road, Bundoran, Co Donegal, has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to two counts of harassing the woman at a location in Dublin on dates between February 18th and March 11th, 2012 and between August 1st, 2012 and February 4th, 2013.
Detective Superintendent Walter O’Sullivan outlined the facts of the harassment to the jury. He said Garda Maguire first met the sergeant at the Dublin Garda Station he was working from in 2011. She believed there was nothing personal in their interaction.
He sent the woman a Valentine’s Card in February 2012 and she spoke with him privately and told him that his attention to her was inappropriate, unwanted and unwelcome. She believed that this would be the end of the matter but Garda Maguire continued to contact her through email via the garda pulse system.
She reported the emails to superior colleagues and Garda Maguire was disciplined and told not to contact her again. The emails continued which resulted in his access to the pulse system being revoked. Garda Maguire then turned up at the garda station where she worked and specifically asked for her. He was again cautioned not to contact the woman.
Three weeks later, he turned up at a garda 10km race she was running in and was noticed by other colleagues to be staring at her. Again his superiors met with him and he gave an oral undertaking not to have any further contact with the woman.
Two weeks later she received a friend request from him on Facebook. This was the final contact before seriousness of the harassment was escalated and investigated as a criminal offence.
The court heard that the harassment impacted on the woman’s work and family life and caused her great stress. She felt physically sick, annoyed and concerned on receiving the communications from Garda Maguire.
She was granted annual leave following the Facebook contact from Garda Maguire because her superiors believed she was not in “a fit position to do her work”.
Det Supt O’Sullivan agreed with Ronan Kennedy BL, defending, that when Garda Maguire was interviewed in June 2013, he said he was infatuated with the woman and this was not reciprocated. He accepted that he had been warned to stop communicating with the sergeant, but had continued contact despite this.
Det Supt O’Sullivan agreed with Mr Kennedy that Garda Maguire had difficulty understanding what he had been doing was wrong and that he had been causing the woman stress. He accepted that, following the interview, both he and his colleagues had concerns for Garda Maguire’s well-being.
Ms Small told the jury in opening the trial that the defence agreed that the accused harassed the woman.
She told the jury it would hear from consultant psychiatrist Dr Brenda Wright on Thursday who would testify that, in her view, Garda Maguire, “didn’t know what he was doing was wrong, was unable to appreciate the significance and wrongness of the act and that he was unable to refrain from doing his actions”.
The trial continues on Thursday before Judge Elma Sheahan and jury of three women and nine men.
Valentine's Card In February 2012 the woman received a Valentine's Card signed by the accused which stated that he never dreamed how wonderful his life could really be until the day "you came along". He said he was so happy, that she meant the world to him and signed it with "love and eternal gratitude".
Garda Maguire had also transcribed the poem, The Cloths of Heaven, by William Butler Yeats, on to the card. The sergeant initially thought it was a joke, but later confirmed it was Garda Maguire's signature and asked to speak to him privately.
He confirmed he had sent the card and she told him that it was totally unwanted and unwelcome. She said they were both married with children, she had no romantic interest in him and if he did it again she would report him.
Garda Maguire seemed unfazed, but she hoped it would be the end of the matter.
A number of days later she was told he had phoned the station looking for her. She wasn’t there and she didn’t return his call. A week later he rang her to tell her he was due to go on leave and there was no one to cover his station.
She told Garda Maguire this was not her responsibility and advised him who to contact. She felt he was using the call as an excuse to speak to her.
On March 6th she got an email from him, through the garda Pulse system, asking for her help in re-housing his Yorkshire Terrier Toto. She was concerned and worried about it and she was angry he had used Pulse to send it.
He had to come off his beat in order to send the mail and she was concerned that he had gone to such lengths to contact her.
Two days later he sent her another email via Pulse apologising, “for all the nonsense I have caused you”. He said he would understand if she were angry with him and signed off saying “I hope everything is good in your life”.
She didn’t reply to the email but three days later got another one through Pulse. It was a joke email that had been circulated with other members of the force.
It was followed by two further emails sent at 3.19am, one of which started “I love you and I want all your life into mine”. The follow-up email corrected an error in the first saying he was “morto”.
Det Supt O’Sullivan said the woman was becoming more upset and frightened and was anxious about opening her emails. She contacted her superior and told him about the card and the emails but didn’t make a formal complaint.
The colleague immediately went out to where Gda Maguire was on duty and spoke to him about the situation. The accused said he was very fond of the woman and had not meant to upset her. He said would not contact her again.
There was no communication for six months until she received an email, again via pulse, from Gda Maguire which said he was just back at work and catching up on things. “Hope all is good with you” he said and signed off as Donal.
She took this as an attempt to reconnect. She was angry but ignored the email. The following day she received another email asking to meet up for coffee.
It was at this point she realised she would have to make a formal complaint to stop the harassment. She went on holidays and returned to the station to hear he had rang for her while she was away.
That same day he turned up at the station looking for her. She went down and spoke to him but the following day she arranged a meeting to make the formal complaint and later submitted a report.
Gda Maguire was dealt with via garda disciplinary regulations but she received another email from him that day saying “I couldn’t help dropping my jaw off your floor. If you find my missing teeth let me know”.
Det Supt O’Sullivan said it was clear to the woman that the Gda Maguire’s warnings had not worked and his access to the Pulse system was revoked. He again undertook not to contact her again.
Garda Maguire then turned up at the Garda 10km run where he was spotted starring at the woman after approaching her to say hello. Although he was also a member of the same running club, other gardaà were surprised to see him there as he usually didn’t participate in the races.
He was again approached by superiors and gave an oral undertaking to leave the woman alone but he went on to send her a friend request on Facebook two weeks later.