Ronan bids to overturn refusal of 10-storey Appian Way apartments

Architects in favour of project argue that proposed building would be ‘local landmark’

Johnny Ronan planned initially  to build a 13-storey high tower on the Appian Way site in Dublin. File  photograph: Collins
Johnny Ronan planned initially to build a 13-storey high tower on the Appian Way site in Dublin. File photograph: Collins

Johnny Ronan planned initially to build a 13-storey tower on the Appian Way site in Dublin where he was recently refused permission for a 10-storey build-to-rent apartment scheme.

That is according to architects for the scheme, Shay Cleary Architects, who are supporting Mr Ronan’s attempt to have Dublin City Council’s planning refusal overturned.

In a submission as part of the appeal lodged on behalf of Mr Ronan’s RGRE and J&R Valery’s Ltd to An Bord Pleanala, the architects state that the 29-studio and 15 one-bedroom apartment scheme was reduced from 13 storeys to 10 after consultation with the council.

Advancing the case for the 10-storey proposal, the architects say “it is our strong contention that the proposed building responds creatively to, and respects and enhances, its context”.

READ MORE

The firm said they proposed the 10-storey building “as a local landmark and focal point”.

A council note of a pre-planning consultation meeting show that it told Ronan group representatives that the 13-storey height would materially contravene the city development plan and the proposal to include 70 per cent of units as studios was unsupported.

Height guidelines

John Spain, a planning consultant for Mr Ronan's group, has told the appeals board that construction of a 10-storey building was supported by height guidelines, that encourage increased density and apartment building heights.

Mr Spain said the site “is capable of carrying a new modern element within the streetscape”.

He notes that the proposed scale, height and layout of the development “provides for an appropriate scale and use of the strategically-located site”.He further argues that “the scale, massing and appearance” of the scheme “makes it visually distinctive contributing to the creation of a strong design response to the site”.

The scheme has faced strong local opposition and Mr Spain added that the proposal “provides for much needed residential accommodation in a high accessible area well served by quality public transport”.

Gordon Deegan

Gordon Deegan

Gordon Deegan is a contributor to The Irish Times