An Irish company which claims it has been wrongly sanctioned by US president Joe Biden for dealing with a Russian entity has launched High Court proceedings over AIB’s decision to freeze its bank accounts.
The action has been brought by Cubit Semiconductor Limited, with a registered address at Milltown, Dublin 6, and its directors Jae Sik Ban and his wife Joung Ok Houng, who are originally from South Korea but are Irish citizens.
The company, which is involved in the sale and supply of new and used semiconductor equipment and had a turnover of €4.9 million in 2023, was the subject of a sanction due to its dealings with Russian entity Mikron KSC which traded successfully since 2011 and in 2023 had a turnover of €4.9 million.
In late March, 2022, it claims a courier was engaged to pick up goods for Mikron from Cubit’s Korean office. The goods were not collected until April 4th, 2022.
Podcast: Terry Prone on allowing son Anton Savage to be in her publicity as a child: ‘I think it was the wrong thing to do’
Man who drowned off Galway coast named as singer-songwriter Johnny Duhan
Woman who alleges she was raped by Conor McGregor had ‘severe’ post-traumatic stress disorder, psychiatrist tells court
Owen Doyle: Ireland must ensure Scott Barrett’s claim about Joe McCarthy is not swept under the carpet
A few days earlier, on March 31st, 2022, the US Department of Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) included Mikron on a list of entities sanctioned due to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
As a result of the transaction being deemed to have taken place after the OFAC’s designation of Mikron as a sanctioned entity, the US imposed sanctions on the plaintiff.
Cubit intends to challenge that decision in the US, which it says is costly and will take time.
The company says it has been left “devastated” and has effectively ceased to trade after it was included on a list of sanctioned entities.
Cubit claims that, after it was included on the list, AIB informed it of its intention to close its accounts. It also suspended or froze its accounts, Cubit claims.
The company claims the US sanction is a “secondary sanction,” as it has no effect in law in Ireland or the EU, and there are no EU or Irish sanctions in place against the firm.
The company’s directors wish to liquidate the firm, but say they are unable to take the necessary steps because its bank accounts are frozen.
As a result of AIB’s action it is claimed that the company cannot deal with parties that owe it money and cannot pay its suppliers or its five employees their salaries.
Represented by Gary McCarthy SC with Michael Devitt BL, instructed by Ogier LLP solicitors, Cubit says it has attempted to resolve matters with the bank.
However, Cubit is not assisted by AIB’s offer of allowing the sum of €232,000 to be paid to facilitate its appeal against OFAC’s decision and to provide the firm with a bank draft for the approximately €2 million sum outstanding.
The bank cannot lodge those funds with another bank and its directors cannot open personal accounts with other banks due to the US sanctions, counsel said.
AIB’s concerns due to the sanctions are understandable and the bank is entitled to close the accounts if it wishes, counsel said, but the sanctions are not enforceable here and it is their case the bank has a contractual obligation to the plaintiff.
Counsel added that the firm does not trade in Russia or the United States, and does not support or operate in an area that supports the Russian military. It has not had any further dealings with any sanctioned entity.
In its proceedings against AIB plc Cubit seeks various orders including injunctions, prohibiting the bank from continuing to freeze or suspend the accounts, or from closing the accounts.
It also seeks a declaration from the court that the bank wrongly suspended or froze the accounts as well as damages for AIB’s alleged breach of contract and duty.
Mr McCarthy added that while proceedings have been brought his client remains hopeful that discussions with AIB might resolve matters without the need for a court hearing.
The matter came before Mr Justice Rory Mulcahy on Friday, who granted the company permission to serve short notice of the proceedings on the bank.
Permission was granted on an ex parte basis. The matter will return before the courts next week.
- Sign up for push alerts and have the best news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone
- Find The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date
- Listen to our Inside Politics podcast for the best political chat and analysis
