Ryanair is ramping up a new subsidiary with weaker labour rights to better compete in eastern Europe, infuriating staff and unions by bypassing concessions granted during a year of industrial strife.
But a key element of the plan, forcing staff to move to self-employment contracts, is being investigated by Polish authorities and a law to allow contractors to join unions – and potentially push for concessions granted in Western Europe – is due to enter force there in January.
Europe’s largest low-cost carrier has seen almost a third wiped off its share value in 12 months since strike threats led it to recognise unions for the first time. Investors fear better staff conditions could undermine its business model, among other issues.
While hailing progress in securing deals on improved conditions with unions across Europe, management is planning the rapid expansion of Polish-registered Ryanair Sun, where staff are self-employed contractors, a model Ryanair has largely phased out at its main airline under union pressure.
The model denies staff normal employment rights such as paid sick leave and effectively blocks union representation, staff and union representatives said.
"On the one hand, Ryanair is busy reaching out to the unions to show a new socially responsible face," said Philip von Schöppenthau, secretary general of pilot group the European Cockpit Association.
“But at the same time they are busy working in the opposite direction building up a potentially union-free – by design union-free – company, Ryanair Sun.”
Ryanair counters that many staff are happy with contractor status, which they say gives them higher pay. It says the contracts are standard in Polish airlines and that the unit’s rapid expansion – from five to 20 planes next year – would not be possible if conditions were not competitive.
"It's not necessarily the best model for union membership growth, so I would expect the unions to say negative things ... But look, it's the way the Polish market works," said chief marketing officer Kenny Jacobs.
Scale of move
Ryanair Sun is currently only operating in Poland, Ryanair's largest market in eastern Europe, and Ryanair declined to say whether it planned to expand the unit to other markets.
But chief executive Michael O'Leary said in July he planned to grow Ryanair Sun and Austrian unit Laudamotion "as quickly as they're able to grow". In October he told investors the two units would drive "much of" the airline's growth.
With more than 200 planes on order over five years, Ryanair has the capacity to build both units into mid-sized European airlines with tens of millions of passengers a year each.
While Laudamotion has signed a collective agreement with its unions, HSBC Bank described Ryanair's new multi-unit structure as "an attempt to counter the pressures of unionisation". Goodbody stockbrokers said Ryanair Sun gave Ryanair "the chance to create an ultra-low cost business".
Mr O’Leary made the decision to recognise unions under the threat of a mass Christmas strike last year, after months of cancellations and an extremely tight global market for pilots. With several union deals done and small airline failures increasing pilot supply, the airline is under less pressure now.
Eastern expansion
Ryanair has singled out central and eastern Europe as a key market for growth, split between “essentially just two airlines” – Ryanair and union-free, Hungary-based Wizz, Mr Jacobs said.
Ryanair says its staff costs were on par with Wizz before the staffing crisis, at €5 per customer flown, but have since grown to €6.
While Ryanair Sun will help Ryanair compete with Wizz in eastern Europe, Wizz is likely to face pressure from unions as it moves into Western Europe, Mr Jacobs said.
Non-unionisation also means Ryanair Sun avoids collective labour agreements that can put restrictions on transfers to other bases.
Moving planes and crew quickly between airports helps give Ryanair the lowest airport costs in Europe – accounting for as much as two-thirds of their cost advantage over some rivals.
Unions say Ryanair is using the unit to put pressure staff in negotiations in other countries. When Irish pilots threatened to strike earlier this year, Ryanair announced it was cutting capacity in Ireland and offered staff jobs at Ryanair Sun.
Threat to model
Prospects for Ryanair Sun and its contractor model will depend in part on how regulators and staff react in the coming months.
Ryanair announced in September that it was liquidating its Polish bases and would offer staff jobs at Ryanair Sun. A memo dated October 1st and sent to all pilots in Poland by chief operations officer Peter Bellew said pilots who do not sign the contracts would not be offered a conversion course for Ryanair Sun "and so we will have no jobs for them in Poland".
Cabin crew were offered the choice of signing the new contracts or taking alternative jobs in the United Kingdom or Germany on the same terms, but crew said the cost of living made the option impractical.
Within days, 300 cabin crew had joined a new union, CWR, which Ryanair has not recognised. Pilots have not yet attempted to unionise.
Ryanair has since convinced more than 100 cabin crew to overcome initial reluctance and sign the contracts. CWR said that was partly through the dismissal of a handful of cabin crew workers on probationary contracts. Ryanair declined to comment.
At least 50 cabin crew are still refusing to sign the contracts under which "any representation such as unions cease to exist" said Paulo Conceicao, the secretary of the CWR union.
But that could change when a Polish law comes into force on January 1st that will give broader powers to employees who want to unionise.
One union source said the law would allow the unions to consider strikes. Two others said the formation of the first dedicated pilot union in Poland may follow some time next year. – Reuters