“Show, don’t tell” is the simplest rule of cinema. Four decades into his storied, Oscar-winning career, Barry Levinson, the director of Rain Man and Good Morning, Vietnam, should know as much. There’s so much mobsplaining in the film-maker’s messy true-life Mafia movie that it often feels like Robert De Niro is aggressively reading a Wikipedia entry. Citation!
Listening to a clutter of archive footage, explanatory radio broadcasts and TV news stories, extensive voiceover, straight-to-camera narration, and interior monologue, one wonders when the film will start. The convoluted Mafia politics keep on coming.
In a gimmicky, prosthetics-heavy flourish, De Niro essays dual – and duelling – roles as Frank Costello and Vito Genovese, two Italian-American associates battling for control of the Luciano crime syndicate in the 1950s. Costello is the gentleman mobster, a bootlegger and bookmaker with links to the Democratic Party and a penthouse suite in New York’s Waldorf Astoria. Vito, a former childhood chum, is a hothead returning from exile, leaving a trail of corpses around his Manhattan territory.
Costello is happily married to his Jewish wife and sounding board, Bobbie (Debra Messing); Frank ends up in a very public and acrimonious divorce case from the similarly heightened Anna (Kathrine Narducci).
Donald Trump says the US is in danger of ‘messaging and propaganda’ from international cinema. Pull the other one
Four new films to see this week
‘Sometimes the reality is more Spinal Tap than Spinal Tap’: Philly Byrne of Gama Bomb on Irish thrash metal and the band’s new film
Alicia Witt: ‘It was a scene that got cut from the movie. I did kiss Madonna in rehearsals’
Nicholas Pileggi, a writer of Martin Scorsese’s Goodfellas, has post-Sopranos fun with wise-guy banter. An exchange concerning Mormon history between Genovese and Cosmo Jarvis’s (future boss) Vincent Gigante becomes so hilariously overheated that it almost results in a road crash. A raid that sends many portly mob bosses running indelicately for the hills deserves a special collective noun. A jiggle of mobsters? A gam of gangsters?
These occasionally fun interludes fail to coalesce into more than a superfluous genre entry. The grand casting gambit of pitching De Niro against De Niro proves an unnecessary distraction. Curiously bloodless in every respect.
