Changes in tax arrangements for company cars will hinder efforts to promote Ireland’s green agenda and cut transport-related carbon, car leasing companies have predicted.
New benefit-in-kind (BIK) tax bands come into effect from January taking CO2 emissions into account for the first time. Simultaneously, the previous zero rate of BIK for electric vehicles is to be slowly phased out.
Critics of the changes have warned it will have the effect of reducing the use of cleaner, modern lease cars and drive employees into less efficient petrol and diesel models. It will also increase minimum rates of tax liability for employees.
The Vehicle Leasing Association of Ireland (VLAI) has said its member companies have been “inundated” with client requests to return company cars ahead of the changes.
How a hotter world is affecting Ireland in five graphics
Cop29 failure unacceptable, even if climate slips from political priorities, warns Eamon Ryan
Torrential rain expected in Malaga and Tarragona as Spain shuts schools and evacuates residents
Cop29 report indicates carbon emissions from fossil fuels set to reach record high in 2024
“The [switch to] private cars for business means these cars will not be as new, as green, as safe or as clean as the company car they are currently driving,” said Dave Kavanagh, VLAI deputy president.
By contrast, the Government has said its policy is focused on strengthening the environmental rationale behind company car taxation. The lower the C02 emissions of a vehicle, the lower the rate of BIK it will attract.
Under the new regime, from January the amount taxable as BIK will be determined by a company car’s original market value (OMV), the annual business kilometres driven and new CO2 emissions-based bands. The flat BIK rate on vans will increase from 5 to 8 per cent.
Separately, the previous zero rate of BIK on electric vehicles worth €50,000 will be phased out. From January, it will be limited to €35,000 of OMV, then to €20,000 in 2024 and €10,000 in 2025.
EVs will be subject to BIK rates ranging from 9 to 22.5 per cent depending on mileage.
Petrol and diesel cars will see rates of up to 37.5 per cent. Speaking last month, outgoing minister for finance Paschal Donohoe said the new approach was “designed to incentivise employers to provide employees with low-emission cars”.
However, the Government had been warned the effect would be contrary to that ambition. The VLAI believes leasing vehicles can play a “significant role” in growing EV use but, in a previous submission to Government, said raising BIK rates would damage this.
Mr Kavanagh said some employees could be tempted to lose their “perk” company cars, replace it with a company car allowance and move to the so-called grey fleet, typically diesel cars between four and eight years old with higher CO2 emissions.
“That goes completely against the Government’s Climate Action Plan because by definition people will buy older, more polluting vehicles,” he said.
Revenue does not keep data on BIK as it applies to company vehicles, so the user effects of the policy shift could be difficult to assess. However, lease companies, which provide many companies with their vehicles, believe it will be a disincentive.
Other concerns have emerged. Although lower BIK rates typically apply to greater mileage, some employees entirely dependent on vehicles, such as retail, medical or pharmaceutical reps, will face higher BIK tax bills under the new band system.
One source familiar with the policy shift said while companies could technically cover a tax increase by raising pay, this is not usual and would simply shift the increase from employee to employer.
Notional values on company cars also bring a PRSI cost to companies.
The minimum BIK rate under the new regulations will apply at 9 per cent, up from 6 per cent on the previous system.
“Potentially people could find themselves paying more benefit in kind tax than they have done before,” the source said, although adding that other tax profiles with more efficient cars could pay less.
