Zero alcohol levels and curfews proposed for young drivers

Zero alcohol levels, night-time curfews and increased penalty points are just some of the proposals up for consideration under…

Zero alcohol levels, night-time curfews and increased penalty points are just some of the proposals up for consideration under the proposed Graduated Driving Licensing (GDL) system for learner drivers.

A consultation process on the system has been initiated by the Road Safety Authority (RSA), with the public asked to share their views on the proposals.

The GDL is aimed at reducing the rate of collisions, deaths and injuries among learner drivers, particularly among 17 to 24 year olds. A number of other countries, including Australia, New Zealand, the US and Canada, have similar systems in place.

However, Fine Gael warned that the proposals would be undermined by cuts in Garda overtime.

READ MORE

If the proposals are implemented, the new legal limit for blood alcohol would be lowered from 80mg per 100ml to 20mg, to allow for the presence of alcohol in small concentrations in everyday products such as mouthwash. The RSA says previous studies have shown that zero alcohol laws decrease crashes in young drivers.

Also up for consideration are increased penalty points for learners, age restrictions on passengers and mandatory tuition. New drivers could also find themselves subject to restrictions on the power of the cars they can drive, hazard perception testing and an upgraded driving test.

The new proposals could see the penalty points threshold for disqualification lowered from 12 to six for new drivers, which the RSA hopes will discourage new drivers from taking risks on the roads.

Currently, power restrictions apply to those with learner permits to drive motorcycles. The RSA is proposing that it be extended to cars, although it did acknowledge that more advanced safety features, such as electronic stability are more often found on higher powered cars.

Chief executive of the RSA, Noel Brett, said the introduction of the GDL played an important part in the Government's Road Safety Strategy 2007 to 2012.

"Learner drivers are vulnerable road users and face greater risks and challenges due to their inexperience. Evidence suggests that the best way to reduce risk is to introduce measures that are designed to protect them until they have built up enough experience behind the wheel," he said.

The restrictions imposed on inexperienced drivers under GDL systems usually apply for up to two years after passing a driving test.

"Some changes have already taken place. For example the old provisional licence has been replaced by a learner permit. All drivers holding a learner permit must now be accompanied by a driver who has held a full licence for a minimum of two years. A person may not take a driving test for six months after gaining a learner permit," Mr Brett said.

Some 279 people were killed on Irish roads last year, 59 fewer than in 2007.

Fine Gael's road safety spokesman, Shane McEntee, said he welcomed the RSA's proposals, but said  the reduction in Garda overtime would have a negative effect on the  plans.

"Far too often we mourn the tragic loss of young life, both drivers and passengers, from car accidents on dark rural roads late at night. The mix of inexperience and the presence of young friends in the car can lead to a lethal combination," he said.

"However, cuts in Garda overtime imposed by Justice Minister Dermot Ahern in this recession have already had a negative impact on road safety enforcement outside of peak hours. If these overtime cuts continue, then the effectiveness of any new driving licence proposals will be seriously undermined."

He also highlighted the implementation of mandatory breath testing at accident scenes.

"This was promised by the Government in October 2007 when it performed a dramatic U-turn on the issue, but the necessary legislation has never been put in place," he said.

"Mandatory testing at accident scenes is already in place in Northern Ireland and many other EU states, and is considered a human rights issue under EU law."

The RSA is accepting submissions on the GDL proposal until March 14th.

Ciara O'Brien

Ciara O'Brien

Ciara O'Brien is an Irish Times business and technology journalist