Caster 16 Leinster 21
It's easy in the cheap seats, and they were also a lot cooler than a battleground bathed in 20-degree sunshine, but as ugly, forgettable away wins go, this was right up there.
The honesty of the effort and work-rate could not be faulted, and Leinster deserved to win for the manner in which they lorded possession and territory, but they rarely looked like doing anything truly creative, much less score a try, and long before the end it was clear they would be indebted to the boot of Ian Madigan. The 25-year-old centre nailed seven penalties from nine attempts from all manner of distances and angles to steer Leinster to their second win out of two in pool two.
Leinster could have few quibbles with referee Greg Garner, who resisted the baying of a classically pantomime French crowd with an 11-6 penalty count in Leinster’s favour.
Torrid time
The performance wasn’t without its wobbles, notably at the set-scrum, where Michael Bent had a torrid time, and even the over-worked Jack McGrath seemed to struggle a little, although there was an improvement when Mike McCarthy was introduced.
The lock also put himself about around the pitch, while Eoin Reddan injected a bit more zip off the base and sniped, in contrast to Isaac Boss, who had unusually declined to do so.
Apart from that, most of Leinster's game was quite static. Operating off slow ball, they didn't come onto the ball with much depth and ran laterally, with an emphasis on inside passes and little by way invention. On the day he became only the third man in European cup history to play 100 games in the tournament, after Ronan O'Gara (110) and John Hayes (101), Gordon D'Arcy had little in the way of good ball or space to work with.
Devin Toner, Jamie Heaslip and Dominic Ryan epitomised the work ethic with big shifts, Zane Kirchner played with assurance at the back, and it was good to see Luke Fitzgerald looking in great nick physically.
Castres may have rested goal-kicking scrum-half Rory Kockott, which led to a late debut for Antoine Dupont, the 17-year-old captain of the French under-18s, but as ever when Irish side have come, this game mattered to Castres, not least as they unveiled their newly built stand, the Tribune Gabarrou, complete with 23 VIP rooms.
Ibrahim Diarra was also promoted to the bench after Mathieu Babillot came into the back-row, meaning they had seven of their starting line-up from last January’s meeting, while injury-riddled Leinster had only eight survivors from Castres’ single home defeat last season.
For all their troubles, Castres only defeat at home this season was in their opening game. Since then they’d won three in a row and three weeks previously had put 50 on Grenoble. So, having taken an early 14-0 lead last January, there was a sense of déjà vu about the way Castres went seven up here.
Following Sean Cronin's crooked first dart, Rémi Talès' perfectly weighted crosskick enabled Max Evans to gather and chip Kirchner, before Fitzgerald recovered to concede the throw. The home pack's low body positioning was tightly choreographed and though Leinster stemmed the drive twice, there was no preventing loosehead Saimone Taumoepeau from touching down. Geoffrey Palis converted.
Spillages
Leinster set about going through the phases, but they lacked penetration and a couple of monster hits by Ramiro Herrera on Kane Douglas and Jimmy Gopperth, along with one by Richie Gray on Bent, forced a couple of spillages.
The home support were whipped up by the gesticulating Herrera after a slow feed from the Leinster scrum enabled Taumoepeau to drive Bent upwards and backwards. That was out of harm’s way though, as Leinster succeeded in managing for the rest of the half – at the end of which they’d enjoyed 73 per cent territory and 64 per cent possession.
Their reward for a solid lineout and plenty of recycling, albeit laboured, were three well -struck penalties by Madigan to punish Talès for going off his feet, Romain Cabannes for a deliberate knock-on and Piula Faasalele for pulling down a Leinster maul.
Restored the lead
Madigan had a chance to extend the lead with the last kick of the half but he pushed a difficult 48-metre penalty wide. Then, after Palis had restored the lead when Bent was driven back again, Madigan hit the outside of the upright to a cacophony of boos and whistles.
Palis was wide from about about 45 metres as suddenly the penalties began to flow for the home side and not just at scrum time. Palis nailed two more to put Castres 16-9 ahead as Garner pinged Boss and Heaslip in turn for side entries at a ruck and maul.
Out of nowhere, although perhaps pointedly at the first complete scrum since the introduction of McCarthy on the tighthead side, Leinster put in a huge shove, which led to a penalty for offside, which Madigan unerringly landed from an angle and 45 metres out.
After another protracted bout of patient recycling – it almost seemed as if Leinster were playing for penalties – Madigan reduced the leeway to a point when Diarra went off his feet, and landed another late brace to a cacophony of boos and whistles.
Leinster closed out the final play in utterly fitting fashion with close-in recycles until the clock turned red and Heaslip nudged the ball over the touchline.
Garner was howled all the way to the dressing-room whereupon the crowd exited. Job done.
Scoring sequence: 5 mins Taumoepeau try, Palis con 7-0; 17 mins Madigan pen 7-3; 26 mins Madigan pen 7-6; 38 mins Madigan pen 7-9; (half-time 7-9); 43 mins Palis oen 10-9; 54 mins Palis pen 13-9; 56 mins Palis pen 16-9; 63 mins Madigan pen 16-12; 70 mins Madigan pen 16-15; 77 mins Madigan pen 16-18; 80 mins Madigan pen 16-21. CASTRES OLYMPIQUE: Geoffrey Palis; Max Evans, Christopher Tuatara, Romain Cabannes, Remi Grosso; Rémi Talès (capt), Cedric Garcia; Saimone Taumoepeau, Brice Mach, Ramiro Herrera, Richie Gray, Rodrigo Capo Ortega, Mathieu Babillot, Yannick Caballero, Puila Faasalele. Replacements: Ibrahim Diarra for Babillot (51 mins), Mathieu Bonello for Mach, Yohan Montes for Herrera (both 67 mins), Christophe Samson for Gray, Antoine Dupont for Garcia (both 70 mins). Not used: Mihaita Lazar, Romain Martial, Julien Dumora. LEINSTER: Zane Kirchner; Darragh Fanning, Gordon D'Arcy, Ian Madigan, Luke Fitzgerald; Jimmy Gopperth, Isaac Boss; Jack McGrath, Sean Cronin, Michael Bent, Devin Toner, Kane Douglas, Rhys Ruddock, Dominic Ryan, Jamie Heaslip (capt). Replacements: Eoin Reddan for Boss (54 mins), Mike McCarthy for Douglas (58 mins), Noel Reid for D'Arcy (61 mins), Richardt Strauss for Cronin, Tadhg Furlong for Furlong (both 70 mins), Jack Conan for Ruddock (73 mins). Not used: Ed Byrne, Mick McGrath. Referee: Greg Garner (England).
