So let’s just get this out there. First up Michael Oliver, who has ties to the UAE, is appointed to referee Manchester City’s biggest game of the season just days after a human who looks like Keir Starmer (there is no proof of this either way) is seen in an Arsenal box, while the UK government is furiously back-channelling UAE trade relations. We’re through the looking glass here people, where even the glass is made of other looking glasses, possibly in Nyon, and probably by Satanists.
Meanwhile, we’re meant to be surprised that VAR didn’t see anything wrong with Erling Haaland throwing the ball at Gabriel’s head (subplot: Brazil recently banned the use of X) even as the UK government seeks a Norway-style deal to covertly sneak back into the European Union. You do the algebra sheeple.
Frankly, some of us saw all this coming when Jared Gillet, an Australian, was appointed to referee the north London derby against Spurs who are managed by an Australian, whose government literally this weekend signed an economic partnership with: Abu Dhabi. While we’re on it, you know who else was Australian? Adolf Hitler. And yet we are supposed to believe that …
Okay, okay, okay. The madness is out there if you want it. The madness is quite tempting because it’s kind of a community vibe and a good way to meet people online and it also makes it feel as though life, which makes absolutely no sense at all, actually has a narrative and shape.
‘We are better with Marcus Rashford’ - Ruben Amorim urges striker to stay at Manchester United
Marcus Rashford ‘ready for new challenge’ as Manchester United exit moves closer
Liverpool’s Arne Slot says Premier League referees are testing his patience
Champions Shelbourne to host Derry City in Premier Division 2025 season opener
Admittedly this does require the holding of contradictory beliefs and the glossing of certain inconvenient facts. For example, if Oliver is a Sky Blue agent, and if we can please accept that chucking the ball away on a yellow is dopey, then the only unarguably key terrible decision during Manchester City versus Arsenal was Oliver calling Kyle Walker over to speak to him and then watching on as Arsenal scored an excellent quick-thinking goal via that same channel of vacated space. Which is quite funny in its sheer howling clumsiness, like being ordered to stop your car by the police who then give you a parking ticket.
Zoom out a little and there are two real-life problems with this stuff, the big ongoing conspiracy game beyond the game that is now a Premier League staple. First, feeling cheated is also often rooted in fact, if not always the most appealing ones. Going down this line often lets people get away with actual, solvable incompetence and stupidity.
In the case of Sunday’s game, the PGMOL and Premier League opened the door to this stuff with two terrible decisions. First, there is no way on this earth or any other that English referees should be off taking paid employment from a state that owns one of the clubs they routinely officiate.
This is not to suggest referees are corrupt (they’re not). But appearance is everything and this is mind-bogglingly careless. You could make a case Howard Webb and anyone else involved at that level should walk now just based on allowing this to happen.
Then of course the Premier League invited exactly this kind of fraying at the edges when it allowed governments to own its member clubs, but that’s a much longer story. Either way, a pretty good rule here is always, always, when it comes to football governance, go with incompetence first. Do you think these people could actually organise an international conspiracy without ballsing that up too?
But the real issue here, the thing that has got a little lost in the wall of rage, is that this was a very good, engrossing game of football. Most of all it was a good game for Arsenal, who showed great fortitude and skill to recover from going a goal down after nine minutes away to the best team on the planet, and from there to come within moments of victory despite having lost a player in the first half. Manchester City’s salvaging of a point was also real (they have a genuine champion spirit) and so were their heartfelt celebrations, the moaning about “dark arts” after drawing with 10 men. This is a compliment. Players know.
Just as interesting is the way Arsenal’s skill at defending has become an issue. There is confusion here. Somehow being good at defending is being cast as controversial or nihilistic, even some kind of fatal hubristic flaw. True, Arsenal celebrate defending more than any other team, to the extent that we can perhaps now look forward to a time when defenders start refusing to celebrate certain tackles and blocks out of respect for former clubs, and are hailed as “classy” as a result.
But it also seems odd to assume defending is not the absolute sandwich bread of elite football, or that being the best defensive team in the league is not a significant shift of power. The fact so many people consume football remotely or in clips is probably part of this. In the flesh, in the stadium, or watching the full 90 minutes on a screen undistracted, high-class defending is one of most thrilling and engaging parts of sport.
Arsenal’s defending on Sunday afternoon wasn’t just beautiful to watch, every part functioning in concert — the right City players given space, the dangerous ones closed down — right up to the moment City cracked this code and managed to get Jack Grealish into the right spot. It is also the part that gives the rest of the game substance, which ennobles attacking moments and makes them robust, that made Erling Haaland’s goal and the work in creating it from Savinho so special, because it came against that defence. Take away this skill, wail over “the dark arts” too much and the spectacle will ultimately lose meaning.
Pep Guardiola knows this of course. His approach has always been about control, and possession as first and foremost a defensive tool. He will admire the job his protege did at the Etihad. Arsenal came to Manchester still missing their most important “flow” player, Martin Odegaard, footballing Swarfega, the lubricant that makes their entire attacking game function.
Is it a flaw to be so reliant on one player? No! Sport is meant to be like this. It’s supposed to involve managing weak spots. Most clubs have internal budget limits, pockets that end somewhere. This is the best part of the financial rules. They make management more of a feat.
Defending is also one part of the game where Arsenal are currently better than City. They came to Manchester with 11 clean sheets in their last 14 Premier League games. Why would anyone not play to that strength? This was a logical approach from Arteta.
Other things were good too. Oliver may have pre-assisted Arsenal’s equalising goal, but Gabriel Martinelli was already pulling very wide as a preset tactic to disconcert Kyle Walker when he went inside as a midfield “underlap”. It was smart play. Jurrien Timber was exceptional. Kai Havertz worked like a maniac.
And looking forward, Arsenal also flagged some of City’s own unresolved issues at what is still an early stage in the season. Walker spent most of the game running around like a man who has lost his keys. Two Arsenal goals made it seven games since City’s last league clean sheet at home. The attack is also an oddity so far. Jeremy Doku still looks like a man playing his own game of dribble ball while an actual football match happens all around him. Only Haaland, Kevin De Bruyne and Mateo Kovacic have scored for City this season and it’s nearly October.
Guardiola is very good at solving these issues on the hoof. This will, as ever, be a different City ream in January. But whatever happens now will also require adjustments to make up for the absence of Rodri for the rest of the season. In many ways this was the key element of Sunday’s game. City have a history of dropping points without their stellar central presence. They were winning on Sunday until Rodri went off.
Handily, while they figure out how to deal with Rodri’s absence, they have a run of games coming that isn’t the most obviously testing. It still seems likely City’s title run will be decided by a spell of nine league games from January 25th that includes Chelsea, Arsenal, Newcastle, Liverpool, and Tottenham, Nottingham Forest and Manchester United away. But Sunday was evidence that Arsenal have the will to chase them to the line again.
The wider narrative isn’t all fiction. The Premier league really is hostage to interests, lobbying, idiocy and incompetence. The day-to-day bit, the ref’s bit, the hands-inside-the-cake-mix stuff, perhaps not so much. For now we can at least take pleasure in an angry, accusatory, defensively venal afternoon of parity.
