Students from Queen’s and Blackhall through to Irish Times debate final

Trinity law professor praises ‘originality’ of arguments on united Ireland motion

Singles winner Dermot Hamill, QUB Literific and David Honeyford MLA, Alliance Party at The Irish Times Debate semi-finals, in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy in  Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
Singles winner Dermot Hamill, QUB Literific and David Honeyford MLA, Alliance Party at The Irish Times Debate semi-finals, in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy in Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw

Students from Queen’s University Belfast (QUB) and the Solicitors’ Apprentice Debating Society of Ireland (Sadsi) have secured spots in the final of The Irish Times third-level debating competition.

Dermot Hamill from the Literary & Scientific Society in QUB progressed as the top individual speaker in the first semi-final on Friday, while Gavin Dowd and Ailbhe Noonan from Sadsi were the team to advance.

The first semi-final of the competition debated the motion: “This House Believes that mandatory Coalition would be necessary in a united Ireland”.

The judging panel included Dr David Kenny, associate professor of law at Trinity College Dublin, Prof Jennifer Todd of the Institute for British–Irish Studies, and Mary Minihan, features editor of The Irish Times.

READ MORE

Bevin Armstrong, the individual winner of the 2021 competition and Dearbhla O’Gorman, 2014 team winner of the competition, were also judges on the panel.

The debate was chaired by Alliance Party MLA David Honeyford.

David Honeyford MLA, Alliance Party with team winners Ailbhe Noonan, and Gavin Dowd (Sadsi) and singles winner QUB Literific Dermot Hamill at The Irish Times Debate semi-finals in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy, Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
David Honeyford MLA, Alliance Party with team winners Ailbhe Noonan, and Gavin Dowd (Sadsi) and singles winner QUB Literific Dermot Hamill at The Irish Times Debate semi-finals in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy, Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw

Speaking after the debate, Dr Kenny said all individuals and teams had shown great “originality” in their arguments.

The topic has been handled “really thoughtfully and sensitively”, with debaters weighing up the question of unity but also the “mechanisms” for how a united Ireland might work, he said.

The decision on which individual and team would advance to the final was “extremely close,” following an “outstanding debate”, he said.

The debate was held in the Royal Irish Academy on Dawson Street, Dublin city centre.

The Irish Times Debate semi-finals, in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy, Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
The Irish Times Debate semi-finals, in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy, Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw

The remaining semi-finals are due to take place on January 20th, January 27th and February 3rd.

Motions due to be debated at the other semi-finals include whether Amhrán na bhFiann could remain as the national anthem in a united Ireland, if unity would threaten the economic interests of the island, and whether young people have “forgotten the lessons of the Troubles”.

The longest running third-level debating competition, The Irish Times debate is in its 63rd year.

Previous winners include broadcaster Marian Finucane, comedian Dara Ó Briain, writer Gerry Stembridge and the late Adrian Hardiman.

Members of the public can attend the debates, with tickets available to book free of charge at: irishtimes.com/events

Gavin Dowd (Sadsi), one of the contestants at The Irish Times Debate semin-finals, in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy, Dublin.  Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
Gavin Dowd (Sadsi), one of the contestants at The Irish Times Debate semin-finals, in partnership with ARINS, at the Royal Irish Academy, Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
Jack Power

Jack Power

Jack Power is acting Europe Correspondent of The Irish Times